How to Create a Restaurant Loyalty Program

How to create a restaurant loyalty program in seven steps, with a cafe stamp card example, a copyable checklist and what each option costs.

Say you own a cafe in San Antonio. A customer buys a coffee on Monday and you never see them again. That is the problem a loyalty program fixes. This post shows how to create a restaurant loyalty program in seven steps, with a worked example and a checklist you can copy.

Key Takeaways

  • A loyalty program is a reason to come back, written down and counted.
  • Pick one reward and one number to watch.
  • A paper card is a fair first test. An app suits you once you know you have regulars.
  • Kin App has a loyalty card with stamps or points built in.

What is a restaurant loyalty program?

It is a deal that rewards a customer for coming back. The customer earns something each visit. After enough visits, they get a reward.

The deal can be a stamp card, a points balance or a plain "tenth coffee is free" rule. All three work the same way. The customer earns, you count, and the reward is paid out.

How to create a restaurant loyalty program: what are the steps?

Follow these seven steps. Each one is short. Copy the list into a note and fill it in.

  1. Write the problem in one sentence. For example: "Customers come once and do not return."
  2. Pick one reward. Make it something you already sell, like a drink or a side.
  3. Pick the number of visits. Ten stamps is common. Choose a number your regulars can reach in a month or two.
  4. Choose how you track it. Paper, points at the register or an app. The next sections compare these.
  5. Tell people at the counter. Say it when they pay. A card nobody hears about does nothing.
  6. Count one number. Count how many new customers come back within 14 days.
  7. Review after four weeks. Keep it, change it or drop it.

Do not add a second reward until step 7 is done. You cannot tell what worked if you change three things.

Which loyalty program examples work for restaurants and cafes?

Three shapes cover most small places. We have not measured any of them for a client, so we list how each one works, not how well.

  • The stamp card. One stamp per visit. The tenth visit earns a free item. This suits a cafe with daily regulars.
  • Points per dollar. The customer earns points on each bill. Points trade for food. This suits a restaurant where the bill changes a lot.
  • A named perk. One thing for regulars only, such as a free refill or a first look at a new dish. This costs little and is easy to explain.

Pick the one a new customer can understand in five seconds.

Should a restaurant use a punch card, points, or an app?

Begin with the cheapest test that gives you a count. That is usually a paper punch card.

A paper card costs almost nothing, but it gets lost and you cannot see who holds one. Points at the register need a till that records them. An app keeps the stamps on the customer's phone and counts them for you.

We build apps, so we lean one way here. We think an app pays off only when you already have regulars. If your customers come once, fix that first with a test card.

An app also has to pass Apple's App Store Review Guidelines before it is listed. That is Apple's rule. Whoever builds your app handles it each time.

Why is a loyalty program important for a restaurant?

A regular is worth more than a stranger, because you already won them. You do not need an ad to reach them. You need a reason for the next visit.

We do not have a sourced industry figure for this, so we will not quote one. Test it in your own shop instead. The counting step in the checklist tells you.

What does a worked example look like?

This is an illustrative example. Every number is an assumption, not a Kin client result.

Item Assumed number
Reward One free drink after 10 stamps
Menu price of the drink $4.50
Cost of making the drink $1.20
Cost of one reward to you $1.20
New customers in the month 100
Came back within 14 days, before the card 20
Came back within 14 days, after 4 weeks of the card 30

Here is how to read it. The card did not give away money. It gave away a drink that costs $1.20 to make. Ten more customers came back in 14 days.

Now redo it with your own numbers. Use your own drink, your own cost and your own count. If the return number does not move, you learned that for the price of one month.

How much does a restaurant loyalty program cost to run?

A paper card costs the print job plus the rewards you give away. We have no price for printing, so check with your printer.

An app costs more, and it does more. Here are our plans.

Kin App Kin App Pro
Setup fee $1,500, once $3,500, once
Monthly price $199 $399
Minimum term 12 months 12 months
Loyalty card Stamps or points Stamps or points
Order ahead and pay in the app No Yes
Website included Core Core

Kin App has a loyalty card inside your own app. You also get push notifications you send yourself, your menu, hours and directions, and two edit requests a month. Kin App Pro adds order ahead and pickup paid in the app, plus two promo notifications a month written by us.

Both plans cover one location. A second location makes it a Custom job.

For the first year of Kin App, that is $1,500 plus 12 times $199. The total is $3,888. That is arithmetic on our posted prices, not a promise of sales.

We have a coffee shop demo app. Payments and orders in our demos are simulated. It shows the screens, not results. We are a small app and web studio in San Antonio.

Where should the program live?

Put the sign-up where customers already look. That is your menu, your counter and your website. A restaurant website that sends people to your card helps people find the program before they visit.

Kin App includes a Core website, so the app and the site come together. Our Core website alone is $79 a month plus $149 setup.

If you want more reward ideas, read more loyalty program ideas for small shops. If you are choosing between tools, see how to compare loyalty programs.

FAQ

How many rewards should I pick first? One. You cannot tell what worked if you change three things at once.

How long before I know if it works? Four weeks is enough to see a change in a number you count weekly.

Do I need an app to run a loyalty program? No. A paper card tests the idea. An app makes sense once you know you have regulars.

Does Kin App Pro have a loyalty card? Yes. It includes everything in Kin App, and adds paid order ahead.

Next step

Write your problem in one sentence and pick your reward. Then look at the Kin App plans if a loyalty card on a phone fits your shop.

Tell us the business and we will tell you which plan fits.